November 19, 2026
Two estates on Park Avenue in Chaine Du Lac closed five weeks apart this fall, and both topped the Orange Observer's weekly Windermere sales list. The first was 12237 Park Ave., built in 2016 with 5,899 square feet. It sold Sept. 24 for $4,000,000 after 19 days on market. The second was a 1995 estate with 7,740 square feet on the same street. It sold Oct. 29 for $4,300,000 after 141 days.
That gap on one street shows up all over this fall's Windermere sales. The Orange Observer published weekly roundups of Windermere and Windermere-area sales from Aug. 6 through Nov. 12, 2026, covering closings from late July to early November. In those reported sales, the median time on market rose as prices rose. But every price tier, and many single communities, held homes that sold within days and homes that waited for months. Price band and gate are a poor guide to how long a house will take. The house itself is the better guide.
The table below sorts every sale in those roundups that listed days on market into three price tiers. A few entries left the figure out, so they are not counted. The set includes Gotha addresses that the Observer groups with its Windermere-area sales, and a sale at exactly $1,000,000 counts in the middle tier.
| Sale price, late July to early Nov. 2026 | Sales with days on market listed | Median days on market | Fastest | Slowest |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Under $1 million | 37 | 26 | 2 | 402 |
| $1 million to $2 million | 20 | about 36 | 2 | 181 |
| $2 million and up | 25 | 79 | 12 | 234 |
The median column follows the familiar pattern, with longer waits at higher prices. The fastest and slowest columns show how loosely that pattern held. Above $2 million, four homes sold in under three weeks and eight took longer than 120 days, all in the same 15 weeks. Below $1 million, 20 of the 37 sales went in under a month. Six others sat for more than 200 days.
Those weeks were also tougher for the whole metro. The Orlando Regional REALTOR Association's September 2026 report put the month's mortgage rate at 7.4%, up from 6.7% in August and the highest since November 2023. Orlando-area sales fell 6.2% from August to September, and homes averaged 66 days on market in September. In that same report, the single-family median was $432,360 for September. Higher rates touched every Windermere seller at once. They do not explain why two houses with the same price and the same rate finished months apart.
Keene's Pointe is the gated golf community around the Jack Nicklaus-designed course at the Golden Bear Club. It had more sales in these roundups than any other community: a dozen, from $900,000 to $3,300,000. Within its gates, the pattern from the table turned around.
The larger homes moved steadily. 6857 Valhalla Way is a 7,153-square-foot house built in 2006, and it sold Aug. 31 for $3,300,000 after 53 days. 6417 Lake Burden View Drive sold for $2,784,000 in 31 days. 9222 Tibet Pointe Circle sold for $2,425,000 in 57 days. 11753 Vinci Drive went for $1,980,000 in 19 days.
Most of the community's sub-$1 million sales took longer. A 2001 home on Bowden Way sold for $960,000 after 130 days, according to the Aug. 27 roundup. Another Bowden Way home sold Nov. 6 for $900,000 after 168 days. A home on Camden Park Drive sold Oct. 1 for $950,000 after 370 days, more than a year.
Claymont Circle shows the spread on a single street. One Claymont Circle home sold Sept. 3 for $950,000 in 10 days. Three weeks earlier, another sold for $1,100,000 after 107 days. A third, sold in August, went for $1,300,000 after 95 days. All three shared a gate, a golf course, an association and a build era of 2001 or 2002. They still finished three months apart.
Keene's Pointe is not the only example. The clearest pairs this fall came from communities where nearly everything but the house was the same.
On Cartmel Lane in the Reserve at Lake Butler Sound, one home sold Aug. 14 for $2,300,000 after 93 days, according to the Aug. 20 roundup. A few doors away, a house built the same year with about the same square footage sold Nov. 4 for $2,250,000 in 12 days.
The Willows at Lake Rhea produced three sales at almost the same price. A home on Kane Park Way sold in August for $960,000 after 213 days. In October, a Willow Gardens Drive home sold for $964,500 in seven days. Two weeks after that, another Willow Gardens Drive home sold for $960,000 in 57 days. Three houses within $4,500 of each other in price finished at 7, 57 and 213 days.
Isleworth's three timed sales split the same way. A 2016 home on Aviva Garden Court sold Nov. 2 for $3,725,000 in 20 days. On the same day, a 1989 home on Isleworth Country Club Drive sold for $2,750,000 in 15 days. Two weeks earlier, a 1988 home on McCormick Place sold for $3,337,000 after 234 days, the longest wait above $2 million this fall. The 1989 house sold in about two weeks and the 1988 house took more than seven months, so the age of the house alone does not explain the gap.
Newer construction did not guarantee speed either. Estancia at Windermere had two 2019 homes on Estancia Woods Loop close this fall. One sold for $1,850,000 after 104 days, and the other sold for $2,150,000 after 155 days.
The longest waits above $2 million came mostly from established estates near the lakes. A 1982 estate in Kelso on Lake Butler, on W. Lake Butler Road, sold Aug. 28 for $2,925,000 after 170 days. A 1986 home on Down Lakeview Circle sold for $3,200,000 after 177 days. A 1999 home in Lake Down Estates sold for $2,583,750 after 153 days. Each of them sold at a price that ranked first or near first for its week. A long wait in this part of Windermere still ended in a multimillion-dollar sale.
At the other end, a house with confirmed water access moved almost at once. 2113 Water Key Drive in Waterford Pointe has a private covered boat dock and direct access to a ski lake. It sold Sept. 28 for $1,650,000 in two days.
The longest waits of the whole season were below $1 million and outside the gated communities. A home in Lake Buynak Estates sold Nov. 6 for $775,000 after 402 days. A Glenmuir home sold in September for $765,000 after 387 days, and a 2021 home in Pearl Lake Park in Gotha sold for $750,000 after 358 days, according to the Sept. 24 roundup. In the same tier, a 1992 home in Citrus Oaks sold for $332,000 in two days, and a Roberts Landing home sold for $835,000 in three.
For someone choosing between Keene's Pointe, Isleworth, the Butler Chain streets and the newer enclaves farther west, this fall's sales point one way. A community's typical time on market says little about the house you are looking at. Above $2 million, a listing at 150 days is in line with what happened on Park Avenue, W. Lake Butler Road and Down Lakeview Circle this season, and each of those homes still closed near the top of its week's sales. Below $1 million, most well-matched homes went in under a month, so a listing that has sat much longer stands apart from its tier.
The number to weigh is how long one particular house has been listed, read against its own street. Claymont Circle, Cartmel Lane and Willow Gardens Drive each produced a fast sale and a slow sale within weeks, at nearly the same price. The Windermere neighborhood page covers the communities themselves. Owners thinking about a spring listing can begin with a home valuation built on the sales nearest their own address.
The Windermere agents at Corcoran Premier Realty follow these closings street by street, from Keene's Pointe and Isleworth to the Butler Chain. We're glad to go through the recent sales near a home you're considering, or near one you own, so you make an offer or set a price knowing how long homes on that street have actually taken. Get in Touch.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
Where to See the Holiday Lights, Concerts, and Parades.
A Guide to Native Florida Landscaping for Beautiful Winter Park Yards.
Fresh Produce, Regional Plants, and Local Finds in Winter Park.
A Closer Look at Mediterranean Revival Architecture in Winter Park, Florida.