November 5, 2026
In May 2008, Kevin and Laurie Tarter opened The Chef's Table inside the 1927 Edgewater Hotel with nine tables, thirty seats and one small kitchen. Eighteen years later the restaurant and its casual sibling, The Tasting Room, have grown to nearly 200 seats. All of them are still served from that same kitchen.
That kitchen is the reason for the move. In July, the restaurants announced they will relocate to the historic Bond Building at the corner of Plant and Main, with openings planned for mid-2027. Until then, service continues at the current location, 99 W. Plant St. That makes this November and December the final holiday season in the rooms where downtown Winter Garden has held 18 years of birthdays, office dinners and engagements.
Chef's Table grew in stages inside the Edgewater. The Cellar Room was added in 2009 to make space for more tables and private parties, and The Tasting Room followed in 2011. Every expansion added seats. None of them added a kitchen.
Two very different dinners come out of that kitchen. At The Chef's Table, the three-course prix fixe is $74.99 per person, with four choices per course, an optional wine pairing, and a usual run time of about two hours. Guests must be older than 8, and OpenTable's listing says pricing may vary on holidays. The Tasting Room serves small plates, large plates and craft cocktails, and it doesn't take reservations. It uses text-ahead seating instead: text 407-230-4837 about thirty minutes before you arrive and the staff will seat you as close to that time as they can. Brunch runs in The Tasting Room on Saturdays and Sundays.
Current hours, per the restaurant's OpenTable listing:
The private rooms are where the small-kitchen layout shows most clearly. Each is priced by food and beverage minimum rather than a room fee. Most have two fixed seatings a night. Here is the lineup from the restaurant's private dining page:
| Room | Capacity | Three-hour seating minimum | All-night exclusive minimum |
|---|---|---|---|
| Chef's Alcove | 8 to 10 | $800+ | $1,600+ |
| Chef's Table Room | Up to 16 at separate tables | $1,500+ | $3,000+ |
| Cellar Room, one large table | 15 to 18 | $1,500+ | $3,000+ |
| Cellar Room, U-shape | 14 to 24 | $1,500+ | $3,000+ |
| Tasting Room | 70 | $6,000 Sunday to Thursday | $10,000 Friday and Saturday |
The three-hour seatings run from 5:15 to 8:15 p.m. or from 8:30 to 11:30 p.m., and the all-night exclusive runs from 5:30 to 11:30 p.m. The restaurant won't hold a room without a deposit and a signed contract, and it notes that all prices are subject to change without notice.
For a group of a dozen, the table shows how the season usually gets planned. The Chef's Alcove tops out at ten, so a dozen guests move up to the Cellar Room or the Chef's Table Room at the $1,500 tier. Two seatings a night means one room can host two parties on a single December evening, and only two. A group large enough to fill The Tasting Room is working with a minimum that is $4,000 higher on a Friday or Saturday than on a weeknight. That gap is reason enough to look at a Tuesday or Wednesday holiday dinner.
The Cellar Room in its current form will last only until the move. The restaurant describes it as a charming space for private parties that was added when the Edgewater had room to grow. In the Bond Building, the private dining will move upstairs.
The July announcement listed these plans for the new space:
The Tasting Room will take the corner storefront at 2 W. Plant St., with The Chef's Table next door at 12 W. Plant St. The staff stays the same. In the announcement carried by PR Newswire, general manager Alicia Havard said, "Our guests will see the same familiar faces and the same experience they've trusted for years." Jim Larweth now owns the restaurants, which the Tarters handed over to him. The West Orange Times & Observer quoted him calling the move "a larger kitchen, more room for guests, new private dining and event spaces and a long-term home in one of Winter Garden's most important historic buildings."
Opening dates, menus and design previews are scheduled for release in the coming months. For now, mid-2027 is a planned window and could still shift.
The Bond Building went up in 1912 as the first brick commercial building downtown after a 1909 fire destroyed all of the wooden buildings. James L. Dillard and Benjamin T. Boyd, both members of Winter Garden's first City Commission, built it. It first housed a bakery and a real estate office. Around 1913, the first Winter Garden theater opened on its second floor and ran until 1917, when the Lyric Theater replaced it. Over the next decades the building held a barbershop on the Main Street side, eighteen boarding rooms upstairs, the Winter Garden Pharmacy, Tibbals-Rexall Drugs and J.S. Reddick's Meat Market, among other businesses.
In 2011, The Bond Foundation renovated the property. One of its buildings had sat empty since a 1979 fire, and the other's second floor had been condemned since the 1960s. The private dining rooms planned for the second floor will put that level back to use with guests in it.
The old rooms and the downtown holiday calendar line up well this year. The Edgewater sits at 99 W. Plant St. and Garden Theatre on Plant is at 160 W. Plant St., so most of these dates fit into a short walk along one street.
The timing on the movie nights is tight. Weeknight dinner at The Chef's Table opens at 5:00 p.m. and generally takes about two hours, so the earliest seating finishes right around a 7:00 p.m. showtime. On those nights, The Tasting Room's text-ahead seating gives you more flexibility before the movie. On any Saturday in the season, the Winter Garden Farmers Market runs from 8:00 a.m. to 1:00 p.m. at the Downtown Pavilion, 104 S. Lakeview Avenue, and brunch at The Tasting Room overlaps its last two hours.
All five Holiday Flix showtimes fall on Tuesdays, and Tuesday is also one of the nights when The Tasting Room's private-event minimum is lowest, at $6,000 rather than the $10,000 it costs on a Friday or Saturday. Each private room has two seatings a night.
If the holidays have you thinking about life in and around downtown Winter Garden, from homes within walking distance of Plant Street to newer communities to the west, the agents at Corcoran Premier Realty know these blocks well and would be glad to talk it through over coffee on Plant Street. Get in Touch.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
Where to See the Holiday Lights, Concerts, and Parades.
A Guide to Native Florida Landscaping for Beautiful Winter Park Yards.
Fresh Produce, Regional Plants, and Local Finds in Winter Park.
A Closer Look at Mediterranean Revival Architecture in Winter Park, Florida.